Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label – How Your Business Benefits From Both

Many sellers who want to gain a foothold on Amazon are faced with the question of which strategy works best for them. Decisions have to be made not only in regard to the regular factors such as price, quality, or shipping costs, but also take into account the popular question: Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label – which one is better?

Today we will explain how this decision can affect your entire seller profile and who should choose which model and why. We will also explain which facts you need to take into consideration before making a decision.

But before we go into detail, let us first take a look at the difference of the goods when it comes to Private Label vs Wholesale.

TL;DR Amazon Wholesale vs. Private Label

Here is a rundown on the topic of Wholesale vs Private Label. Selling on Amazon is time-consuming work and you don’t always have the time to go through every topic in detail. So here are the most important facts.

Amazon sellers often face the dilemma of choosing between Wholesale and Private Label strategies when searching for new product ideas, especially because most sellers have both types in their inventory, which makes the research for specific topics quite tedious. This decision influences your seller profile and requires evaluation of products, branding, and market approach. Here is what you need to know about Private Label:

On the other hand, here is what you need to look at when you want to sell Wholesale:

Ultimately, the choice between Wholesale and Private Label products depends on your long-term business goals, investment capacity, and willingness to build a brand from scratch versus leveraging existing brand equity. Both strategies have unique opportunities: Private Labels allow brand building and expansion, while Wholesale is better for beginners learning Amazon’s marketplace. Regardless of the choice, tracking performance and optimizing revenue flow is essential. Tools like SELLERLOGIC Business Analytics streamline this process, identify profit killers and bestsellers, and therefore, ensure profitability.

What Is Amazon Private Label?

The difference between Private Label and Wholesale products has a lot to do with the seller. When it comes to Private Label, it means that you yourself have to establish a new brand. This means that you are responsible for expanding the brand and raising awareness. You also take responsibility for the products sold under this brand. 

Nowadays, nobody has to build up his own factory in the backyard to sell a new product. You can much rather use online platforms like Alibaba or GlobalSources. There are many manufacturers, mostly from Asia, who sell their goods to sellers. You can choose and order the product you want to sell under your Private Label – let’s take toothbrushes for the example we will use throughout this article. You also have the option of ordering personalised packaging and the printing of your logo on the product. In this manner, you and other sellers can retail a toothbrush of their own brand.

What Is Amazon Wholesale?

For Amazon sellers, this question is an absolute essential piece of info. In contrast to Private Label products, already established brands can be used for Wholesale. For example, sellers can resell toothbrushes from Oral-B – a huge toothbrush company – on Amazon. The brand is already well-known and customers will specifically search for this brand when interested in an electric toothbrush. As a seller of Wholesale goods, the main challenge for you is not to establish your brand but rather to win the Buy Box.

Some differences are recognisable at first glance. A closer look, however, reveals many more differences that should be considered when choosing the appropriate strategy.

Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label: What’s the Difference? 

To shed more light on this, we have to look at the following areas: Price, investment, Buy Box, legal responsibility and opportunities & risks. We will now discuss these in detail and in order to approach our goal of deciding whether Amazon Wholesale or Private Label is the right thing for you.

Pricing 

Your final selling price on Amazon is influenced by all the costs you incur until your product reaches the customer – including profit. The costs for selling on Amazon, shipping etc. – regardless if you use a Private Label or Wholesale – are similar to each other. However, there are drastic differences in the costs until you are ready to sell on Amazon:

Pricing for Private Label Sellers

Compared to Wholesale, the purchase price for Private Label products is lower because you buy generic, unbranded items. However, Private Label sellers face additional costs that Wholesale sellers do not. We will explore these costs further in the ‘Investments’ section.

When you create a Private Label product, you create a new item with a unique EAN, making you the sole seller without direct competition. This absence of a price war gives you more flexibility in setting your prices. However, while you avoid competition for the Buy Box, you still face competition in search results where buyers can compare your prices with other brands or Private Label products. If you’re already selling and want to boost your sales, the SELLERLOGIC Repricer is the solution for you, as it automatically adjusts your B2B and B2C prices for maximum competitiveness and revenue.

Pricing for Wholesalers

Since sellers of Wholesale buy products of an already established brand, the purchase price is much higher than the price of no-name products. Besides a margin for the brand owner, you pay for the research and development of the product, the marketing of the producer, etc. The high purchase price naturally has a negative effect on your profit, but also on the investments you have to make. 

Your sales price is also significantly influenced by the prices of your competitors. As a seller of Wholesale, you sell the same product (with the same EAN) like many others. Amazon uses the EAN to determine whether a product is already listed or whether it is a new product. Since only one listing is allowed for identical products at a time, wholesalers are competing for the Buy Box and are thus in a direct price war with competitors. wholesalers are correspondingly inflexible in terms of pricing.

Investments

In order to expand an online business, some investments are required. For example, sellers have to procure the goods. Since sourcing varies according to strategy, this has an impact on the amount of investment required.

Investments for Private Label Sellers

Since you still have to build up a brand with your Private Label, your investments will be significantly higher than for Wholesale goods. For example, sellers should invest in a professionally designed label and take marketing measures to create brand awareness. Photos from websites like Alibaba often lack quality. Therefore, sellers should invest time and resources in creating high quality images of the product. Also, sellers need to have an EAN created for the product, which Amazon will use to determine whether the product is already listed or whether a new product page will be created. 

Building a new brand is a task that takes time and effort. But if sellers are willing to take this time, the chances of establishing a strong brand image will increase immensely. In addition to the costs of building up and expanding the brand, sellers often have to deal with even larger purchase quantities and shipping costs from suppliers in other EU countries. Be sure to take this into account. 

Investments for Wholesalers

The abovementioned investments do not have to be taken into consideration by wholesalers, as they rely on an already existing brand. They only have to buy and distribute the goods. A strong brand has already invested in development and expansion. In addition, many sellers of trade goods rely on products from the EU. These have a lower minimum purchase quantity on the one hand and on the other hand, do not have to be imported from Non-EU countries.

Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label: Winning the Buy Box

On Amazon, everything revolves around the Buy Box. But even here there are some differences depending on whether you sell a Private Label or Wholesale.

Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label: Buy Box for Private Label Sellers

Through Private Labels, sellers avoid competing for the Amazon Buy Box. That’s because Private Label sellers are the only supplier of the product to win the Buy Box as long as they are authorised to do so. 

As a Private Label seller you won’t have any competition for the buy box, but that doesn’t mean that there will be no competition at all. While you may already have customers who specifically look for your brand, there are other “non-branded” consumers who still need convincing that you are the best choice among all the other options in the result list. 

Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label: Buy Box for Wholesalers 

As a Wholesaler, you are in a direct price war with your competitors, of which each one wants to get into the Amazon Buy Box. These sellers have to pull out all the stops to become number one for this product including the use of Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), which is a must as if you want to increase the chances of getting into the Buy Box.

But one of the most important criteria for winning the Buy Box is probably the price. Since you are in competition with other wholesalers, it is essential to regularly review and adjust your price. Save time and resources by using a flexible repricer. It will automatically set the best price to win the Buy Box and beat the best price for the seller. 

Legal Responsibility

The question  whether to go for Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label is one that also includes the legal liability of sellers. Owners of a trademark are bound by the Product Liability Act, which holds the manufacturer liable for the product. This can be the case in the event of an accident caused by this product. In terms of legal responsibility, it is therefore important to distinguish whether you are the manufacturer, importer or seller. The decision whether you are selling Private Label or Wholesale also makes an impact here. 

Responsibility of Private Label Sellers

The question whether to sell Amazon Private Label vs Wholesale is not seldomly decided based on the legal responsibility the role entails. If one of your products malfunctions and causes damages, you will not only suffer from a tarnished brand image but also face legal consequences.

If you purchase goods from non-EU countries, you become the importer and therefore responsible for these goods. Additionally, all products sold in the EU should be marked with the CE seal. The tests and test reports that may be required for this seal can be very expensive and it would be wise to check how much they will amount to in total so that you can adjust your price.

This is by far not the only EU customs regulation. As an importer, you are responsible for the customs-compliant import of the goods. Check out the customs webpages for more info, here is the British one for example. If you want to keep it simple, it is therefore advisable to primarily purchase goods from the EU since they were either manufactured here or already brought into the country by another importer.

Responsibility of Wholesalers

Once you let the whole Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label question play out, you can see that the responsibility of Wholesale sellers in regard to legal obligations is by far not as extensive as for Private Label sellers. They are not liable for the product itself, since the liability lies with the manufacturer (in our toothbrush example, this would be Oral-B). The obligations of the importer are also reduced to zero through sourcing, i.e. product procurement in the EU. The responsibility of this also lies with the manufacturer, as he/she imports the goods from the non-EU country. Accordingly, the conformity marking we mentioned before (CE) is also not something that you have to worry about if you are a Wholesale seller.

Opportunities and Risks

You can see, as shown in the previous sections, that both strategies have their advantages and disadvantages. Let’s take a final look at the opportunities and risks of each strategy and decide the question: Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label, which products should I sell?

Opportunities and Risks of Private Label Sellers

YOU are the brand and therefore get to influence the image of your product and much more. But you also bear more responsibility. As described above, you are liable for your brand and the products you sell. If your brand is not well received, this will affect your sales and therefore your profitability. 

As the owner of the brand, Amazon also gives you the opportunity to customise the item description. This allows you to make your texts SEO-compliant and achieve a higher visibility. Once you have established your brand, you can think about expanding and, as part of a diversification strategy, add more goods to your product range in order to win new markets. 

Last but not least, as the owner of a Private Label, you also have the opportunity to sell your brand itself. 

Opportunities and Risks of Wholesalers

Especially for beginners on Amazon, juxtaposing Wholesale vs Private Label is an important starting point. If you are new to the online marketplace, it would make sense to first sell Wholesale in order to gain experience. Find out how Amazon works, what makes customers stick and see how you can fit best into the marketplace. This way, you can also learn how to make your store sustainable or how to communicate with customers – and all this at a lower business risk than with a Private Label on Amazon.

However, with Wholesale, you don’t have the opportunity to build your own brand to which you can later add more products to grow further. 

If you want to sell Wholesale on Amazon that is already listed, you have to assign your product to the already existing product page and therefore have no influence on its design. With a bit of luck, you will be added to a well maintained, SEO-compliant site. However, it can also happen that the creator of the product page was not very skilled in the design and you have to live with the consequences.  

Performance tracking is crucial for both business models 

Whether you decide to sell Wholesale or Private Label products on Amazon, profitability is the key factor in both settings. It is therefore crucial to be aware of your business performance and to eliminate profit drainers as fast as possible. For this purpose, Amazon sellers have to deal with Amazon-related data analysis, which usually turns out to be very complex and time-consuming – as long as it is performed manually. Using a software-based solution instead is a by far more efficient option. 

SELLERLOGIC Business Analytics was developed specifically for Amazon sellers and provides a detailed overview of relevant product data in a profit dashboard – up to two years retrospectively from the point of registration. This allows you to track your performance on global, account, marketplace, and product level. Once you have identified unprofitable products or specific profit-reducing costs, you can take steps to optimize your strategies to stop revenue leakage and to maintain a sustainable business on Amazon.

Amazon Private Label vs Wholesale – Which One Is Right for You?

So, Amazon Wholesale vs Private Label? Who would win for you? Fact is, if you are an experienced Amazon seller and also happen to know a lot about branding and marketing, trying to sell as the owner of your Private Label might be the right way for you. You can use your skills to increase your visibility and sales on the online platform. If you are relatively new on Amazon, it might make more sense to sell Wholesale and gather a few impressions first. Let us not forget, however, that both options carry the same amount of risk. There is no right or wrong here and all we can give you in this article is what we have experienced ourselves or heard from clients. We are sure that you will find your own, most profitable, way. Good luck! If you want more tips on how to sell successfully on Amazon, click on this link to read the article.

FAQs

Image credits in order of appearance: © alexmishchenko – stock.adobe.com / © radachynskyi – stock.adobe.com / © Amazon – amazon.com / © AA+W – stock.adobe.com